[Videoconferencing] Changes to TRIUMF eZuceSRN/SeeVoghRN service

Stanley Yen stan at triumf.ca
Mon Oct 29 10:24:56 PDT 2018


I agree that Zoom is far superior to eZuce.
I believe Fermilab provides  Zoom accounts for all Fermilab users.

Similarly, some Canadian universities (e.g. Laurentian) have provided

Zoom accounts for all their faculty.
TRIUMF should consider doing the same.
   Stan Yen


________________________________
From: Videoconferencing <videoconferencing-bounces at trmail.triumf.ca> on behalf of Thomas Lindner <lindner at triumf.ca>
Sent: Monday, October 29, 2018 10:09:42 AM
To: Andrew Daviel; Akira Konaka
Cc: Videoconferencing at trmail.triumf.ca
Subject: Re: [Videoconferencing] Changes to TRIUMF eZuceSRN/SeeVoghRN service

Hi Andrew,

My two cents: I have used zoom, bluejeans and eZuce for the last couple
years.  My opinion is that zoom and bluejeans are far superior
products.  They have better features and more reliable connections.  We
also found that eZuce often put out software updates which didn't work
on all operating systems.  I always recommend people to use Zoom or
Bluejeans and I actively discourage using eZuce.

I'm sure we would need to pay for Zoom and bluejeans.  I know that
SuperCDMS people use a zoom instance at Fermilab; don't know how much it
costs.

We might pay a little more for these other services.  But ezuce is
cheaper because it is a worse service.

Cheers,
Thomas


On 2018-10-26 5:25 PM, Andrew Daviel wrote:
> On Thu, 25 Oct 2018, Akira Konaka wrote:
>
>> Dear Andrew.
>>
>>  Recently, some collaborations are moving away from eZuceSRN which
>> sometimes
>> have connection problems. ZOOM and Bluejeans seem to have stable
>> connections,
>> and I found both are very reliable. KEK has recently adopted
>> Vidyo.developed
>> at CERN as well. Is Vibe considered providing more stable
>> connections? Would it be
>> worth considering some of these other tools?
>
> Vibe has some changes, described as
>
> New Features!
>
>         H.264 SVC Codec: Better video over poor connections
>         Enhanced Chat Experience: Persistent chat for rooms and
> private chat
>         SIP Softphone: Connect to your organizations phone system
>         Applications Tabs: Web apps open while in meetings
>         Easy access to community meetings: Connect with colleagues easier
>         And many more!
>
> They have also updated the Panda servers (the concentrators that do
> transcoding and replication, such as the one we host here).
>
> So there may be some noticable improvements.
>
> Vidyo as I recall was an existing commercial product which CERN
> decided to adopt, not a CERN software. (irrelevant, I know)
> As I recall, CERN host a Vidyo server, which is used for e.g. ATLAS
> meetings. That costs something like $30,000. There is one at BC.net
> which we might be able to use. I don't doubt there are some ongoing
> service costs as well.
>
> I don't know the costing model for Bluejeans or Zoom.
>
> For Vibe/eZuce, we pay an annual fee, prorated since we host a Panda
> server, giving us unmetered usage for any TRIUMF user. There are still
> a fair number of meetings being booked.
>
> The issues in room 223 are separate
>
> Andrew
> _______________________________________________
> Videoconferencing mailing list
> Videoconferencing at lists.triumf.ca
> http://lists.triumf.ca/mailman/listinfo/videoconferencing


_______________________________________________
Videoconferencing mailing list
Videoconferencing at lists.triumf.ca
http://lists.triumf.ca/mailman/listinfo/videoconferencing
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.triumf.ca/pipermail/videoconferencing/attachments/20181029/3c4bd355/attachment.html>


More information about the Videoconferencing mailing list